Reputable Rescues

What is the best way to select a reputable non-profit rescue?

Selecting a reputable non-profit dog rescue that does NOT buy dogs from Amish auctions or puppy mills takes some extra research and asking the right questions. Sadly, not all groups calling themselves “rescues” follow ethical animal welfare practices. Reputable rescue organizations focus on animal welfare and transparency. They should be comfortable answering tough questions about how they get their dogs and how they spend donations.

Verify Non-Profit Status

A reputable rescue is usually a registered 501(c)(3) nonprofit in the U.S. You can verify this via IRS tools, Charity Navigator, Guidestar, or by asking for their EIN.

Check Transparency & Public Accountability

Look for:

• Clear mission statement and policies on their website
• Published annual reports and financial statements showing how funds are used
• Willingness to talk openly about where their dogs come from

Ask Where Dogs Come From

A reputable rescue should:

• Be willing to describe how dogs enter the rescue (owner surrenders, shelter transfers, etc.)
• Provide intake records for each dog
• Not be routinely offering lots of young puppies

Expect A Comprehensive Adoption Process

Reputable rescues focus on matching dogs with the right homes, not just a quick placement. The matching process includes:

• Application
• Veterinary references
• Phone or in-person interview
• Home visit
• Written adoption contract
• Return policy if things don’t work out

Watch for Puppy Mill Red Flags in “Rescue” Profiles

STAY AWAY if a rescue’s current dogs are mostly:

• Very young purebreds (unless it is a breed specific rescue)
• Fee structure that feels like a sales pitch
• Frequent animal transport from distant states
• Little documentation on health and/or behavior history

See What Others Say

Do some online research:

• Search the rescue’s name with “reviews,” “complaints,” “scam,” “puppy mill” to see what others have reported
• Look for vet or shelter partnerships listed on their site
• Check social media & third-party review sites